Five formalizations
Parent: stages-and-gates
Same skeleton, five lenses:
- Automaton / recognizer — stages = states, gates = guarded transitions (
advanceenabled iff criteriongholds). The machine recognizes trajectories that clear every gate; it doesn't generate them → recognizer-not-generator. - Hoare logic / proof obligations (deepest) —
{P} S₁ {Q}; {Q} S₂ {R}. The intermediate assertionQis the gate: the owner writes the assertions, the agent supplies an execution satisfying the triple. Gate = a proof obligation; stage = the (possibly neural) tactic → lcf-for-labor. - Options / hierarchical RL (Sutton) — an option
⟨I, π, β⟩: initiation setI, intra-policyπ(free execution), terminationβ= the gate. A stage is an option; HRL = stages-within-stages (recursion). - Supervisory control (Ramadge–Wonham) — the gate disables the controllable
advanceuntil the completion event is observed: "commit unreachable until green." Veto, not command → ramadge-wonham-supervisory-control. - Real options / staged financing — escalating commitment = a compound option; each gate buys the right (not the obligation) to fund the next stage. Turns one big bet into a chain of abortable small options.